Repairing Lime Mortar in Traditional Stone Walls

Why Lime Mortar Belongs in Old Walls
Walk through almost any British village and you can date a wall by its mortar. The soft, sandy, slightly friable stuff between the stones of a medieval church nave or a Georgian garden wall is lime mortar, and it behaves in a completely different way to the hard grey cement that replaced it during the twentieth century.
Lime mortar is permeable and relatively soft. It allows moisture vapour to move through the wall, so water that soaks in after a week of driving rain can evaporate out again rather than being trapped. It also accommodates slight movement — the gentle settlement, thermal expansion and frost heave that every old building experiences — without cracking. Cement, by contrast, is rigid, strong and largely impermeable. Point a rubble stone wall with it and the wall will find somewhere else to release its moisture: usually through the stones themselves, which then spall and crumble as the water freezes inside them.
Reading the Wall Before You Touch It
Before mixing anything, diagnose. Repointing is not a cure for damp, and it will not fix a wall that is wet for another reason. Look for the telltale signs:
- Joints that are hollow, powdery or receding well behind the stone face
- Hard cement pointing, often proud of the stone and cracked along its length
- Crumbling or flaking stone surfaces, especially just above the cement band
- Green algae, dark staining or salt blooms that reappear after dry weather
- Failed gutters, blocked gullies, raised ground levels or soil piled against the base
Deal with the water first. Clear the gutters, lower the ground where you can, and check that downpipes discharge well away from the wall. Vegetation, particularly ivy and valerian, should be cut back carefully and the roots allowed to die off rather than being ripped out, which can pull the stones apart.
Choosing the Right Lime Mix
There are two broad families to consider. Non-hydraulic lime putty, made from fat lime, is the softest, most breathable and slowest-setting option. It is ideal for soft, porous stones and sheltered inland sites, but it needs warm, damp, frost-free weather to cure properly. Natural hydraulic lime (NHL) sets more quickly and is more tolerant of damp conditions. It is graded by strength — NHL 2, NHL 3.5 and NHL 5 — and the golden rule is to choose the weakest grade that will do the job.
The mortar should always be weaker and more porous than the stone it binds. That way, any decay happens in the joint rather than in the masonry, and future generations can rake it out without damaging the wall. For most traditional pointing, a mix of roughly one part lime to two and a half or three parts sand by volume works well, though local practice varies. Use well-graded sharp sand, ideally matched to the colour and texture of the original aggregate, and mix only what you can use in a day.
Preparing the Joints
Rake out the old mortar to a depth of about one and a half to two and a half times the width of the joint, and no less than 20mm for a typical wall. Work with hand tools — a plugging chisel, a small cold chisel, a pointed iron and a stiff brush. Power tools and angle grinders are far too aggressive for historic masonry and will bruise the stone edges in seconds.
Where cement pointing has to come out, take your time and go carefully. Once the joints are clean, brush out all dust and then dampen the stone with a fine mist of water. A damp surface stops the lime giving up its moisture to the wall too quickly, which is the commonest cause of weak, crumbly pointing.
Pointing and Finishing Well
Press the mortar firmly into the joint in layers if it is deep, working it back against the stone with a pointing iron so there is genuine contact rather than a shallow plug. Let it stiffen slightly — a few hours for lime putty, much less for NHL — then finish the surface with a churn brush or a piece of wood. This knocks back the lime and exposes the sand, giving the joint a textured, slightly open face that weathers beautifully and lets moisture move.
Do not trowel the joint smooth and flat as you would with cement. A flush or slightly recessed, brushed finish suits traditional walls; a hard, glossy, proud bead of mortar does not, and will simply trap water and crack.
Curing, Aftercare and Getting Help
Lime needs time and moisture to cure. Keep the new work damp for several days by covering it with damp hessian and misting it morning and evening in warm weather, and protect it from sun, drying wind and frost. Lime putty pointing should be kept above freezing for at least a fortnight. Never seal the wall with a water-repellent coating afterwards; you would undo everything the lime is there to do.
Work in spring or early autumn, in small sections, and let each area finish before moving on. For churches, listed buildings and anything in a conservation area, you will usually need consent before starting — a faculty for Church of England buildings, listed building consent elsewhere — and it is worth talking to your conservation officer and a contractor experienced in historic fabric. Quinquennial inspection reports are a good place to start when planning repairs. None of this is beyond a careful, patient owner, but on a church tower or a fourteenth-century chancel, expert hands will save you both money and heartache.

4 Comments